Lally,
Jaskerit
English
201
Research
Paper Draft
Is Happiness An Emotion Or A State
Of Mind?
What is happiness? This
question has no straightforward answer, because the meaning of the question
itself is unclear. What is the question really asking? The dictionary has
already given the definition of happiness. I, for one, don’t care about what
the definition is. The real question should be what is it that makes us happy? In
order to answer that question, we must first figure out if happiness is an
emotion, or a state of mind.
For hundreds of years,
there have been so many theories about what happiness is. Philosophers and
psychologists came up with so many ideas but not one of them could agree with
each other. Aristotle thought that happiness is an essential motive of human
life and an end in itself. He was convinced that happiness is the key component
for a happy life, which requires physical and mental well-being. Aristotle has
presented ‘Theory of Happiness’ in his “NicomacheanEthics”, which is significant
till today. For him, happiness is an end in itself and it is the
natural desire of humankind. Aristotle writes:
“He
is happy who lives in accordance with complete virtue and is sufficiently
equipped with external goods, not for some chance period, but throughout a
complete life time.”(Nicomachean
Ethics, 1101a10)
According
to Aristotle, happiness consists in achieving, through the course of a whole
lifetime, all the goods — health, wealth, knowledge, friends, etc. — that lead
to the perfection of human nature. This requires us to make our own choices,
some of them may be hard, while the others may be easy. Aristotle makes
important difference between right desire and wrong desire. According to him
what we naturally desire is the need and need is always right desire while what
we want is always apparently good and in reality it is wrong desire. Aristotle
considers that happiness is good as a whole for human life. What he means is
that a life must be completed or ended before we judge whether it was a happy
life or not.
Bertrand
Russell, the philosopher put happiness into two categories: plain and fancy, or
animal and spiritual, or of the heart and head. According to Russell
(1932), complicated emotions make us unhappy. One does not need to go through a
lot for simple emotions. Basically calling happiness a simple emotion.
In The Conquest of Happiness Russell
gives general requisite conditions of happiness as:
“Happiness...depends
partly upon external circumstances and partly upon oneself...Certain things are
indispensable to the happiness of most men, but these are simple things: food
and shelter, health, love, successful work and respect of one’s own herd. To
some people parenthood also is essential. Where these things are lacking only
the exceptional man can achieve happiness” (Bertrand R, The Conquest of
Happiness London: George Allen &Unwin Ltd., 1932), 241.
Most of religions have considered the notion of
happiness. In religious context, happiness and suffering are both parts of
human life. Buddha held that one can gain happiness if one remains away from
the worldly desires. A person, who hides one’s emotions and acts wisely, can
achieve true happiness. It is due to the ignorance, hatred, feelings of winning
or losing, anger that people suffer. According to Buddha when one purifies
one’s soul from all above mentioned evils then one can pursue final happiness
named as ‘Nirvana’. Now Buddha’s concept of Nirvana is similar to Plato’s
theory of the “Ultimate Good” which can only be achieved by suppressing
cravings and lustful desires. The only difference is that Plato’s Good was
beyond reach but happiness is achievable.
Positive psychology is the study of happiness and
something that focuses more on people’s positive emotions than on their
negative emotions, such as depression, anger, and stress. The American
psychologist Martin Seligman invented the term ‘Positive Psychology’. In one of
his articles, “A Balanced Psychology and a Full Life”, Seligman has the idea of
happiness divided into three main points. The first being pleasure, or positive
emotion, the second being engagement, and the third was meaning. Seligman
claimed that you could measure happiness. Having those three things in life
makes you the happiest person.
So what does happiness mean? Happiness is sometimes
associated with pleasure in the moment. The term pleasure is usually used for a
limited sense of natural high. Happiness on the other hand is a long-term
feeling, a sense that life is going well. Everybody wants that feeling rather
than only a temporary feeling of pleasure. Talking about happiness isn’t
complete unless you mention the many different concepts associated with it. Happiness
is considered to be related with ‘psychological good life’. Hugh Hefner
proposed the psychological good life in 1956 as part of his “playboy philosophy.”
According to psychologists there are some basic emotions and some ‘positive
emotions’. The basic emotions are more in number than positive emotions.
According to Ekman and
Friesen (1989), the basic emotions are happiness, sadness, fear, anger,
surprise, and disgust. In the article “Emotion” by Ronald De Sousa, De Sousa
says that emotions are simply a type of feeling that differs based on the circumstances.
William James and Carl G. Lange introducing the “James-Lange” theory brought in
a psychological point of view to the concept of emotions. The theory states
that emotions are feelings caused by the situations you’re in. According to this theory, witnessing an external stimulus
leads to a physiological reaction. Your emotional reaction depends upon how you
interpret those physical reactions. For example, you are walking in the woods
and you see a grizzly bear. You begin to tremble and your heart begins to race.
The James-Lange theory proposes that you will interpret your physical reactions
and conclude that you are frightened "I am trembling, therefore I am
afraid."
If you were able to
choose to be happy, I think everyone in the world would be happy. Mike Maddock
wrote an article called, “Happiness Is a Choice”. In the article, he writes
about how he believes that happiness can be chosen. Basically, summing it all
up, he says happiness is a state of mind. If we choose to look at every
situation in a positive way, we can be happy. “The gift of happiness can and
will affect every aspect of your life, including work.” (Maddock, M).
Why is happiness a
state of mind? According to Ashley Fern, it is something you can control. In
her article “Why Happiness Is a State of Mind”, Fern lists a few things she
believes can make us happy. Surrounding ourselves with the people we love and
love us is one way our happiness is guaranteed. One of the
biggest challenges in life is learning to accept people for who they truly are.
Once you realize that your expectations cannot change people, the better off
you will be. We should keep our heads always from our past and focus more on
the future. How will you be happy if you spend every day of your life
regretting an old decision you made? Once you start taking this advice and
applying it on yourself, you might just turn out to be pretty happy.
There are two
theories of happiness I am familiar with, Hedonism and the Life Satisfaction
theory. Like I mentioned before. Pleasure is often associated with happiness.
Hedonism is a school of thought that argues that pleasure is the primary or most important
intrinsic good. Hedonists usually define pleasure and pain broadly, such that
both physical and mental phenomena are included. Now there are many different
types of hedonism. Folk hedonism, which is commonly referred to as the
“everyday hedonism.” Value hedonism is a theory about value, where all pleasure
hedonism is valuable and all pain hedonism is invaluable. Prudential Hedonists usually understand that
going after pleasure and avoiding pain in the very short-term is not always the
best strategy for achieving the best long-term balance of pleasure over pain.
Motivational hedonism is the theory that the desires to encounter pleasure and
to avoid pain guide all of our behavior. Normative hedonism is the theory that
states happiness should be pursued. Pleasure over pain. Hedonistic egoism is the
theory that we should do whatever is most in our own interests. Lastly, Hedonistic
Utilitarianism that the right action is the one that produces the greatest net
happiness for all. Life Satisfaction theories identify happiness with having a
positive attitude toward one's life.
Is
happiness a choice? Can we control what makes us happy? I believe we can. I
just think that we should stop chasing the idea of happiness. If we just live
in the moment, it’ll be so much easier for happiness to find its way to you. Focusing
on the present moment is crucial; if you spend your time wallowing in the past
or worrying about the future, you are only going to stress yourself out. Learn
to depend on yourself rather than others to bring you fulfillment. Only once
you are happy on your own, can you hope to share your happiness with others.
You cannot hope to have any sort of successful relationship, whether it’s in
the platonic sense, romantic sense or business sense. If you aren’t comfortable
with yourself, how do you ever expect any relationship to begin?
There’s
no doubt that happiness is also an emotion. In psychology, emotion is often
defined as a complex state of feeling that results in physical and
psychological changes that influence thought and behavior. When you’re happy,
you tend to look at things differently. Your facial expressions change, and so
do your actions. Like I mentioned before, the James-Lange theory suggests that
we feel first. Smiling is often associated with happiness. “I am smiling,
therefore I am happy.”
Happiness
is related with the inner world of a person. It is normally found that when one
is happy from one’s heart, one enjoys in any situation, but when one is sad,
one is feeling sadness in every situation. Happiness is a term that relates to
all kinds of emotions like contentment, joy, pleasure, satisfaction,
comfortable, merry, bliss, and well being. All in all, happiness is not an abstract
thing but an achievable emotion. One can learn the art of being happy by
adapting a positive approach towards life engaging in religion, and positive
psychology. Therefore, I believe happiness is both an emotion and a state of
mind.